I already made those settings. See the screenshot where the backend looks right and the frontend looks like nothing changed. None of my changes are being applied.
Thank you for sharing the screenshots and the admin access.
During the investigation, I noticed that some CSS styles from the theme are overriding the pagination styles on the website.
( those styles are coming from this file: yourwebsite.com/wp-content/themes/dt-the7/css/main.min.css )
To fix this, you can include the following CSS code in the view's "Custom CSS" field: